Tuesday, January 1, 2013

Give Up on the Constitution?

Let’s Give Up on the ConstitutionBy LOUIS MICHAEL SEIDMAN

Published: December 30, 2012

.AS the nation teeters at the edge of fiscal chaos, observers are reaching the conclusion that the American system of government is broken. But almost no one blames the culprit: our insistence on obedience to the Constitution, with all its archaic, idiosyncratic and downright evil provisions.



Consider, for example, the assertion by the Senate minority leader last week that the House could not take up a plan by Senate Democrats to extend tax cuts on households making $250,000 or less because the Constitution requires that revenue measures originate in the lower chamber. Why should anyone care? Why should a lame-duck House, 27 members of which were defeated for re-election, have a stranglehold on our economy? Why does a grotesquely malapportioned Senate get to decide the nation’s fate?



Our obsession with the Constitution has saddled us with a dysfunctional political system, kept us from debating the merits of divisive issues and inflamed our public discourse. Instead of arguing about what is to be done, we argue about what James Madison might have wanted done 225 years ago.



As someone who has taught constitutional law for almost 40 years, I am ashamed it took me so long to see how bizarre all this is. Imagine that after careful study a government official — say, the president or one of the party leaders in Congress — reaches a considered judgment that a particular course of action is best for the country. Suddenly, someone bursts into the room with new information: a group of white propertied men who have been dead for two centuries, knew nothing of our present situation, acted illegally under existing law and thought it was fine to own slaves might have disagreed with this course of action. Is it even remotely rational that the official should change his or her mind because of this divination?



Constitutional disobedience may seem radical, but it is as old as the Republic. In fact, the Constitution itself was born of constitutional disobedience. When George Washington and the other framers went to Philadelphia in 1787, they were instructed to suggest amendments to the Articles of Confederation, which would have had to be ratified by the legislatures of all 13 states. Instead, in violation of their mandate, they abandoned the Articles, wrote a new Constitution and provided that it would take effect after ratification by only nine states, and by conventions in those states rather than the state legislatures.



No sooner was the Constitution in place than our leaders began ignoring it. John Adams supported the Alien and Sedition Acts, which violated the First Amendment’s guarantee of freedom of speech. Thomas Jefferson thought every constitution should expire after a single generation. He believed the most consequential act of his presidency — the purchase of the Louisiana Territory — exceeded his constitutional powers.



Before the Civil War, abolitionists like Wendell Phillips and William Lloyd Garrison conceded that the Constitution protected slavery, but denounced it as a pact with the devil that should be ignored. When Abraham Lincoln issued the Emancipation Proclamation — 150 years ago tomorrow — he justified it as a military necessity under his power as commander in chief. Eventually, though, he embraced the freeing of slaves as a central war aim, though nearly everyone conceded that the federal government lacked the constitutional power to disrupt slavery where it already existed. Moreover, when the law finally caught up with the facts on the ground through passage of the 13th Amendment, ratification was achieved in a manner at odds with constitutional requirements. (The Southern states were denied representation in Congress on the theory that they had left the Union, yet their reconstructed legislatures later provided the crucial votes to ratify the amendment.)



In his Constitution Day speech in 1937, Franklin D. Roosevelt professed devotion to the document, but as a statement of aspirations rather than obligations. This reading no doubt contributed to his willingness to extend federal power beyond anything the framers imagined, and to threaten the Supreme Court when it stood in the way of his New Deal legislation. In 1954, when the court decided Brown v. Board of Education, Justice Robert H. Jackson said he was voting for it as a moral and political necessity although he thought it had no basis in the Constitution. The list goes on and on.



The fact that dissenting justices regularly, publicly and vociferously assert that their colleagues have ignored the Constitution — in landmark cases from Miranda v. Arizona to Roe v. Wade to Romer v. Evans to Bush v. Gore — should give us pause. The two main rival interpretive methods, “originalism” (divining the framers’ intent) and “living constitutionalism” (reinterpreting the text in light of modern demands), cannot be reconciled. Some decisions have been grounded in one school of thought, and some in the other. Whichever your philosophy, many of the results — by definition — must be wrong.



IN the face of this long history of disobedience, it is hard to take seriously the claim by the Constitution’s defenders that we would be reduced to a Hobbesian state of nature if we asserted our freedom from this ancient text. Our sometimes flagrant disregard of the Constitution has not produced chaos or totalitarianism; on the contrary, it has helped us to grow and prosper.



This is not to say that we should disobey all constitutional commands. Freedom of speech and religion, equal protection of the laws and protections against governmental deprivation of life, liberty or property are important, whether or not they are in the Constitution. We should continue to follow those requirements out of respect, not obligation.



Nor should we have a debate about, for instance, how long the president’s term should last or whether Congress should consist of two houses. Some matters are better left settled, even if not in exactly the way we favor. Nor, finally, should we have an all-powerful president free to do whatever he wants. Even without constitutional fealty, the president would still be checked by Congress and by the states. There is even something to be said for an elite body like the Supreme Court with the power to impose its views of political morality on the country.



What would change is not the existence of these institutions, but the basis on which they claim legitimacy. The president would have to justify military action against Iran solely on the merits, without shutting down the debate with a claim of unchallengeable constitutional power as commander in chief. Congress might well retain the power of the purse, but this power would have to be defended on contemporary policy grounds, not abstruse constitutional doctrine. The Supreme Court could stop pretending that its decisions protecting same-sex intimacy or limiting affirmative action were rooted in constitutional text.



The deep-seated fear that such disobedience would unravel our social fabric is mere superstition. As we have seen, the country has successfully survived numerous examples of constitutional infidelity. And as we see now, the failure of the Congress and the White House to agree has already destabilized the country. Countries like Britain and New Zealand have systems of parliamentary supremacy and no written constitution, but are held together by longstanding traditions, accepted modes of procedure and engaged citizens. We, too, could draw on these resources.



What has preserved our political stability is not a poetic piece of parchment, but entrenched institutions and habits of thought and, most important, the sense that we are one nation and must work out our differences. No one can predict in detail what our system of government would look like if we freed ourselves from the shackles of constitutional obligation, and I harbor no illusions that any of this will happen soon. But even if we can’t kick our constitutional-law addiction, we can soften the habit.



If we acknowledged what should be obvious — that much constitutional language is broad enough to encompass an almost infinitely wide range of positions — we might have a very different attitude about the obligation to obey. It would become apparent that people who disagree with us about the Constitution are not violating a sacred text or our core commitments. Instead, we are all invoking a common vocabulary to express aspirations that, at the broadest level, everyone can embrace. Of course, that does not mean that people agree at the ground level. If we are not to abandon constitutionalism entirely, then we might at least understand it as a place for discussion, a demand that we make a good-faith effort to understand the views of others, rather than as a tool to force others to give up their moral and political judgments.



If even this change is impossible, perhaps the dream of a country ruled by “We the people” is impossibly utopian. If so, we have to give up on the claim that we are a self-governing people who can settle our disagreements through mature and tolerant debate. But before abandoning our heritage of self-government, we ought to try extricating ourselves from constitutional bondage so that we can give real freedom a chance.

Louis Michael Seidman, a professor of constitutional law at Georgetown University, is the author of the forthcoming book “On Constitutional Disobedience.”



30 comments:

Anonymous said...

xanyh [url=http://www.drdrebeatsbuycheap.com]beats by dre[/url] alnsn http://www.drdrebeatsbuycheap.com lftxa [url=http://www.drdrebeatscheapest.com]beats by dre[/url] lccrt http://www.drdrebeatscheapest.com wvwpe [url=http://www.drdrecheapbeats.com]beats by dre cheap[/url] ltmsd http://www.drdrecheapbeats.com pinjs [url=http://www.drdreoutletstores.com]beats by dre[/url] gfvbx http://www.drdreoutletstores.com zdicd [url=http://www.cheapestdrdrbeats.com]cheap beats by dre[/url] rkify http://www.cheapestdrdrbeats.com xkrfg [url=http://www.cheapbeatsdrdrestores.com]beats by dre cheap[/url] zescc http://www.cheapbeatsdrdrestores.com wpyo

Anonymous said...

dmoao [url=http://www.drdrebeatsbuycheap.com]beats by dre[/url] cmvep http://www.drdrebeatsbuycheap.com hrkhg [url=http://www.drdrebeatscheapest.com]cheap beats by dre[/url] lcbrv http://www.drdrebeatscheapest.com mynvb [url=http://www.drdrecheapbeats.com]beats by dre[/url] lzlyc http://www.drdrecheapbeats.com oqdty [url=http://www.drdreoutletstores.com]cheap beats by dre[/url] yrfgk http://www.drdreoutletstores.com gqcej [url=http://www.cheapestdrdrbeats.com]cheap beats by dre[/url] obhty http://www.cheapestdrdrbeats.com okbga [url=http://www.cheapbeatsdrdrestores.com]beats by dre[/url] ddles http://www.cheapbeatsdrdrestores.com xtkh

Anonymous said...

zerzz [url=http://www.drdrebeatsbuycheap.com]cheap beats by dre[/url] grqbm http://www.drdrebeatsbuycheap.com ykzsn [url=http://www.drdrebeatscheapest.com]beats by dre[/url] wqghz http://www.drdrebeatscheapest.com jibav [url=http://www.drdrecheapbeats.com]cheap beats by dre[/url] jwuon http://www.drdrecheapbeats.com ohxti [url=http://www.drdreoutletstores.com]beats by dre[/url] giqbc http://www.drdreoutletstores.com rdrps [url=http://www.cheapestdrdrbeats.com]beats by dre sale[/url] qitov http://www.cheapestdrdrbeats.com dteos [url=http://www.cheapbeatsdrdrestores.com]beats by dre[/url] fubvt http://www.cheapbeatsdrdrestores.com atcx

Anonymous said...

wsopa [url=http://www.drdrebeatsbuycheap.com]cheap beats by dre[/url] lvwqg http://www.drdrebeatsbuycheap.com rvvyw [url=http://www.drdrebeatscheapest.com]beats by dre[/url] njlfl http://www.drdrebeatscheapest.com uqbpb [url=http://www.drdrecheapbeats.com]beats by dre cheap[/url] kbmxk http://www.drdrecheapbeats.com mjqqo [url=http://www.drdreoutletstores.com]beats outlet[/url] pqilp http://www.drdreoutletstores.com hoxig [url=http://www.cheapestdrdrbeats.com]beats by dre sale[/url] uryuu http://www.cheapestdrdrbeats.com lupek [url=http://www.cheapbeatsdrdrestores.com]beats by dre[/url] rvovf http://www.cheapbeatsdrdrestores.com kpmg

Anonymous said...

hpmtt [url=http://www.drdrebeatsbuycheap.com]beats by dre[/url] nbewd http://www.drdrebeatsbuycheap.com vtofb [url=http://www.drdrebeatscheapest.com]cheap beats by dre[/url] lnwqs http://www.drdrebeatscheapest.com lzoks [url=http://www.drdrecheapbeats.com]cheap beats by dre[/url] onime http://www.drdrecheapbeats.com snlmb [url=http://www.drdreoutletstores.com]beats outlet[/url] yldkp http://www.drdreoutletstores.com tvxah [url=http://www.cheapestdrdrbeats.com]cheap beats by dre[/url] ccbdo http://www.cheapestdrdrbeats.com tzfnr [url=http://www.cheapbeatsdrdrestores.com]cheap beats by dre[/url] kgwxe http://www.cheapbeatsdrdrestores.com mzvf

Anonymous said...

oscok [url=http://www.drdrebeatsbuycheap.com]beats by dre cheap[/url] dpton http://www.drdrebeatsbuycheap.com kmsvu [url=http://www.drdrebeatscheapest.com]cheap beats by dre[/url] fqtoy http://www.drdrebeatscheapest.com poxea [url=http://www.drdrecheapbeats.com]beats by dre[/url] jqbkh http://www.drdrecheapbeats.com xmxcz [url=http://www.drdreoutletstores.com]cheap beats by dre[/url] bnaqv http://www.drdreoutletstores.com klrsh [url=http://www.cheapestdrdrbeats.com]beats by dre[/url] egotv http://www.cheapestdrdrbeats.com cliwt [url=http://www.cheapbeatsdrdrestores.com]beats by dre[/url] ikuco http://www.cheapbeatsdrdrestores.com qcmh

Anonymous said...

jclhs [url=http://www.drdrebeatsbuycheap.com]beats by dre[/url] escds http://www.drdrebeatsbuycheap.com lodnu [url=http://www.drdrebeatscheapest.com]beats by dre cheap[/url] kldmf http://www.drdrebeatscheapest.com oxzmy [url=http://www.drdrecheapbeats.com]beats by dre[/url] xyqbz http://www.drdrecheapbeats.com ercgg [url=http://www.drdreoutletstores.com]beats by dre[/url] yviay http://www.drdreoutletstores.com jthgs [url=http://www.cheapestdrdrbeats.com]beats by dre[/url] gsqfi http://www.cheapestdrdrbeats.com iixes [url=http://www.cheapbeatsdrdrestores.com]cheap beats by dre[/url] lncni http://www.cheapbeatsdrdrestores.com lpsf

Anonymous said...

ykzlz [url=http://www.drdrebeatsbuycheap.com]beats by dre[/url] gwkgo http://www.drdrebeatsbuycheap.com hkura [url=http://www.drdrebeatscheapest.com]beats by dre[/url] bikoy http://www.drdrebeatscheapest.com amlqk [url=http://www.drdrecheapbeats.com]beats by dre[/url] unlgs http://www.drdrecheapbeats.com vcdew [url=http://www.drdreoutletstores.com]beats by dre[/url] mczzg http://www.drdreoutletstores.com bbzjx [url=http://www.cheapestdrdrbeats.com]beats by dre sale[/url] jjdfq http://www.cheapestdrdrbeats.com qzoks [url=http://www.cheapbeatsdrdrestores.com]beats by dre[/url] turep http://www.cheapbeatsdrdrestores.com rlhj

Anonymous said...

ihoyh [url=http://www.drdrebeatsbuycheap.com]cheap beats by dre[/url] gdyoc http://www.drdrebeatsbuycheap.com owzci [url=http://www.drdrebeatscheapest.com]cheap beats by dre[/url] aafos http://www.drdrebeatscheapest.com vqaxg [url=http://www.drdrecheapbeats.com]cheap beats by dre[/url] alafw http://www.drdrecheapbeats.com ttwyh [url=http://www.drdreoutletstores.com]beats by dre[/url] nbjfh http://www.drdreoutletstores.com vpdhw [url=http://www.cheapestdrdrbeats.com]beats by dre sale[/url] lxoho http://www.cheapestdrdrbeats.com iumlo [url=http://www.cheapbeatsdrdrestores.com]beats by dre[/url] bihdu http://www.cheapbeatsdrdrestores.com ruja

Anonymous said...

avvgs [url=http://www.drdrebeatsbuycheap.co.uk]dre beats[/url] ctzva http://www.drdrebeatsbuycheap.co.uk oepnf [url=http://www.drdrebeatscheapest.co.uk]dr dre beats[/url] yizck http://www.drdrebeatscheapest.co.uk dspjx [url=http://www.drdrecheapbeats.co.uk]cheap beats[/url] fhmrd http://www.drdrecheapbeats.co.uk iuyoo [url=http://www.drdreoutletstores.co.uk]beats outlet[/url] dzfhj http://www.drdreoutletstores.co.uk eysgn [url=http://www.drdreheadphonessales.co.uk]beats by dre[/url] npapr http://www.drdreheadphonessales.co.uk petgt [url=http://www.cheapbeatsdrdrestores.co.uk]cheap beats by dre[/url] htfro http://www.cheapbeatsdrdrestores.co.uk cjrr

Anonymous said...

xtmtv [url=http://www.get-canadagoose.com]canada goose outlet[/url] fdbup http://www.get-canadagoose.com zxnzq [url=http://www.pick-canadagoose.com]canada goose sale[/url] xwkbg http://www.pick-canadagoose.com cxetw [url=http://www.pay-canadagooseoutlet.com]canada goose outlet[/url] yfgwg http://www.pay-canadagooseoutlet.com ymten [url=http://www.online-canadagooseoutlet.com]canada goose jacket[/url] wscqo http://www.online-canadagooseoutlet.com tuig [url=http://www.celinebagonsale1.com]celine bags[/url] yfyeh http://www.celinebagonsale1.com elgr [url=http://www.celinebags-onsale.com]celine bag[/url] rosxv http://www.celinebags-onsale.com dfkn

Anonymous said...

pggdk [url=http://www.get-canadagoose.com]canada goose outlet[/url] ylzlc http://www.get-canadagoose.com kpotq [url=http://www.pick-canadagoose.com]canada goose jacket[/url] tcsbj http://www.pick-canadagoose.com imaxx [url=http://www.pay-canadagooseoutlet.com]canada goose outlet[/url] kmvlo http://www.pay-canadagooseoutlet.com ntrlz [url=http://www.online-canadagooseoutlet.com]canada goose[/url] yflwr http://www.online-canadagooseoutlet.com lata [url=http://www.celinebagonsale1.com]celine bag online[/url] zyfqj http://www.celinebagonsale1.com yspg [url=http://www.celinebags-onsale.com]celine bag online[/url] qchss http://www.celinebags-onsale.com ysmh

Anonymous said...

wcgrh [url=http://www.get-canadagoose.com]canada goose jackets[/url] rrdik http://www.get-canadagoose.com mijas [url=http://www.pick-canadagoose.com]canada goose[/url] ypwfz http://www.pick-canadagoose.com ppamj [url=http://www.pay-canadagooseoutlet.com]canada goose jacket[/url] tzmfb http://www.pay-canadagooseoutlet.com znflk [url=http://www.online-canadagooseoutlet.com]canada goose outlet[/url] vpvbr http://www.online-canadagooseoutlet.com iqir [url=http://www.celinebagonsale1.com]celine bag[/url] anepj http://www.celinebagonsale1.com jbfz [url=http://www.celinebags-onsale.com]celine bags[/url] axpsu http://www.celinebags-onsale.com gdzf

Anonymous said...

thriy [url=http://www.get-canadagoose.com]canada goose outlet[/url] sjcue http://www.get-canadagoose.com wtiuw [url=http://www.pick-canadagoose.com]canada goose sale[/url] jxgbs http://www.pick-canadagoose.com atcwi [url=http://www.pay-canadagooseoutlet.com]canada goose jacket[/url] gtbbd http://www.pay-canadagooseoutlet.com gagvk [url=http://www.online-canadagooseoutlet.com]canada goose[/url] bmlat http://www.online-canadagooseoutlet.com ansa [url=http://www.celinebagonsale1.com]celine bag[/url] rpfqe http://www.celinebagonsale1.com dhdl [url=http://www.celinebags-onsale.com]celine bag online[/url] ulgcq http://www.celinebags-onsale.com uccf

Anonymous said...

lbptd [url=http://www.get-canadagoose.com]canada goose jackets[/url] swlfg http://www.get-canadagoose.com pdhhi [url=http://www.pick-canadagoose.com]canada goose jacket[/url] yqbtq http://www.pick-canadagoose.com iplxu [url=http://www.pay-canadagooseoutlet.com]canada goose[/url] hgqui http://www.pay-canadagooseoutlet.com yraeg [url=http://www.online-canadagooseoutlet.com]canada goose jacket[/url] kyzjp http://www.online-canadagooseoutlet.com hnnj [url=http://www.celinebagonsale1.com]celine bag online[/url] upkyb http://www.celinebagonsale1.com mtbb [url=http://www.celinebags-onsale.com]celine bags[/url] usant http://www.celinebags-onsale.com tien

Anonymous said...

wvqhb [url=http://www.get-canadagoose.com]canada goose outlet[/url] rsmiv http://www.get-canadagoose.com muagu [url=http://www.pick-canadagoose.com]canada goose sale[/url] dsdxf http://www.pick-canadagoose.com xfjru [url=http://www.pay-canadagooseoutlet.com]canada goose[/url] ftobl http://www.pay-canadagooseoutlet.com afeyc [url=http://www.online-canadagooseoutlet.com]canada goose jacket[/url] wnsqm http://www.online-canadagooseoutlet.com nqka [url=http://www.celinebagonsale1.com]celine bags[/url] demfl http://www.celinebagonsale1.com prhr [url=http://www.celinebags-onsale.com]celine bag[/url] tlodd http://www.celinebags-onsale.com vhbg

Anonymous said...

rjpwm [url=http://www.get-canadagoose.com]canada goose jackets[/url] kmaxo http://www.get-canadagoose.com vhsvo [url=http://www.pick-canadagoose.com]canada goose[/url] xnysd http://www.pick-canadagoose.com znehp [url=http://www.pay-canadagooseoutlet.com]canada goose jacket[/url] jrwez http://www.pay-canadagooseoutlet.com iunlm [url=http://www.online-canadagooseoutlet.com]canada goose jacket[/url] xdhmq http://www.online-canadagooseoutlet.com dput [url=http://www.celinebagonsale1.com]celine bags[/url] mzcbf http://www.celinebagonsale1.com hmnt [url=http://www.celinebags-onsale.com]celine bag online[/url] qhplk http://www.celinebags-onsale.com jbjj

Anonymous said...

qlofb [url=http://www.get-canadagoose.com]canada goose[/url] fawnv http://www.get-canadagoose.com ergec [url=http://www.pick-canadagoose.com]canada goose[/url] ixumd http://www.pick-canadagoose.com ylpsx [url=http://www.pay-canadagooseoutlet.com]canada goose jacket[/url] cbrpy http://www.pay-canadagooseoutlet.com fldpc [url=http://www.online-canadagooseoutlet.com]canada goose jacket[/url] ydpte http://www.online-canadagooseoutlet.com dvnw [url=http://www.celinebagonsale1.com]celine bags[/url] xonqa http://www.celinebagonsale1.com sfau [url=http://www.celinebags-onsale.com]celine bag online[/url] czpvp http://www.celinebags-onsale.com muek

Anonymous said...

xodya [url=http://www.get-canadagoose.com]canada goose[/url] xmkal http://www.get-canadagoose.com qfhdb [url=http://www.pick-canadagoose.com]canada goose jacket[/url] svnwk http://www.pick-canadagoose.com hfcyh [url=http://www.pay-canadagooseoutlet.com]canada goose[/url] fbhoc http://www.pay-canadagooseoutlet.com tizlv [url=http://www.online-canadagooseoutlet.com]canada goose[/url] lxozp http://www.online-canadagooseoutlet.com widj [url=http://www.celinebagonsale1.com]celine bags[/url] fycih http://www.celinebagonsale1.com tcps [url=http://www.celinebags-onsale.com]celine bag[/url] bfuej http://www.celinebags-onsale.com hgsq

Anonymous said...

hbtaw [url=http://www.get-canadagoose.com]canada goose outlet[/url] hujqw http://www.get-canadagoose.com nvtfp [url=http://www.pick-canadagoose.com]canada goose sale[/url] jrlel http://www.pick-canadagoose.com cctmj [url=http://www.pay-canadagooseoutlet.com]canada goose outlet[/url] lblof http://www.pay-canadagooseoutlet.com lplvy [url=http://www.online-canadagooseoutlet.com]canada goose jacket[/url] zrguf http://www.online-canadagooseoutlet.com wtqb [url=http://www.celinebagonsale1.com]celine bag online[/url] xhboo http://www.celinebagonsale1.com qxlm [url=http://www.celinebags-onsale.com]celine bags[/url] snbvo http://www.celinebags-onsale.com wegx

Anonymous said...

tkyfxs http://au-louisvuittonoutlet.com lcexhv http://www.hots-canadagooseoutlet.com uinfru http://www.montblanc-sale-us.com yirepk http://cheaperbeatsbyydre.com qgaajv http://fox-louisvuittonoutlet.com sdqosn [url=http://au-louisvuittonoutlet.com]louis vuitton outlet[/url] mavnj [url=http://www.hots-canadagooseoutlet.com]canada goose outlet[/url] velqq [url=http://www.montblanc-sale-us.com]mont blanc pens[/url] vyuah [url=http://cheaperbeatsbyydre.com]beats by dre[/url] zullzr [url=http://fox-louisvuittonoutlet.com]louis vuitton outlet[/url] khfv

Anonymous said...

uldnue http://au-louisvuittonoutlet.com lbucyp http://www.hots-canadagooseoutlet.com lwzxdm http://www.montblanc-sale-us.com bhpyfm http://cheaperbeatsbyydre.com hwcxwq http://fox-louisvuittonoutlet.com szijbs [url=http://au-louisvuittonoutlet.com]louis vuitton outlet[/url] hnnjx [url=http://www.hots-canadagooseoutlet.com]canada goose outlet[/url] lbfhp [url=http://www.montblanc-sale-us.com]mont blanc pens[/url] zreyd [url=http://cheaperbeatsbyydre.com]dr dre beats[/url] sntagm [url=http://fox-louisvuittonoutlet.com]louis vuitton sale[/url] vmvf

Anonymous said...

aubwbx http://au-louisvuittonoutlet.com shdpzz http://www.hots-canadagooseoutlet.com toghik http://www.montblanc-sale-us.com uedoll http://cheaperbeatsbyydre.com azvplz http://fox-louisvuittonoutlet.com whclbx [url=http://au-louisvuittonoutlet.com]louis vuitton outlet[/url] rtzvn [url=http://www.hots-canadagooseoutlet.com]canada goose jacket[/url] yrbth [url=http://www.montblanc-sale-us.com]mont blanc[/url] boedt [url=http://cheaperbeatsbyydre.com]beats by dre[/url] ddqabi [url=http://fox-louisvuittonoutlet.com]louis vuitton sale[/url] xdbv

Anonymous said...

hcxcue http://au-louisvuittonoutlet.com xjgqlp http://www.hots-canadagooseoutlet.com cwwppe http://www.montblanc-sale-us.com blxewd http://cheaperbeatsbyydre.com qnkzom http://fox-louisvuittonoutlet.com nzpjdj [url=http://au-louisvuittonoutlet.com]louis vuitton sale[/url] mroxx [url=http://www.hots-canadagooseoutlet.com]canada goose outlet[/url] lnzxz [url=http://www.montblanc-sale-us.com]cheap mont blanc[/url] vgezw [url=http://cheaperbeatsbyydre.com]dr dre beats[/url] vnfndy [url=http://fox-louisvuittonoutlet.com]louis vuitton sale[/url] tzrm

Anonymous said...

vjqqwg http://au-louisvuittonoutlet.com hghpgr http://www.hots-canadagooseoutlet.com uupzqw http://www.montblanc-sale-us.com knyrjc http://cheaperbeatsbyydre.com lhiwwj http://fox-louisvuittonoutlet.com espjnq [url=http://au-louisvuittonoutlet.com]louis vuitton outlet[/url] ioljo [url=http://www.hots-canadagooseoutlet.com]canada goose outlet[/url] zbwmw [url=http://www.montblanc-sale-us.com]mont blanc pens[/url] ouzmg [url=http://cheaperbeatsbyydre.com]cheap beats by dre[/url] hfcllo [url=http://fox-louisvuittonoutlet.com]louis vuitton sale[/url] oezd

Anonymous said...

spkpav http://au-louisvuittonoutlet.com gixxje http://www.hots-canadagooseoutlet.com rtejwv http://www.montblanc-sale-us.com tmcfwx http://cheaperbeatsbyydre.com zqptcj http://fox-louisvuittonoutlet.com gcuely [url=http://au-louisvuittonoutlet.com]louis vuitton sale[/url] mbarj [url=http://www.hots-canadagooseoutlet.com]canada goose jacket[/url] rwmck [url=http://www.montblanc-sale-us.com]mont blanc[/url] aenok [url=http://cheaperbeatsbyydre.com]dr dre beats[/url] fplgct [url=http://fox-louisvuittonoutlet.com]louis vuitton sale[/url] aqmr

Anonymous said...

imgalb http://au-louisvuittonoutlet.com lbeqvj http://www.hots-canadagooseoutlet.com ofmnfp http://www.montblanc-sale-us.com tvufbe http://cheaperbeatsbyydre.com rhpxxb http://fox-louisvuittonoutlet.com lwjsnh [url=http://au-louisvuittonoutlet.com]louis vuitton outlet[/url] nxrhl [url=http://www.hots-canadagooseoutlet.com]canada goose jacket[/url] plbri [url=http://www.montblanc-sale-us.com]cheap mont blanc[/url] dffbb [url=http://cheaperbeatsbyydre.com]cheap beats by dre[/url] dckipe [url=http://fox-louisvuittonoutlet.com]louis vuitton bags[/url] mbgy

Anonymous said...

dzjvhx http://au-louisvuittonoutlet.com qfyhom http://www.hots-canadagooseoutlet.com bdrreh http://www.montblanc-sale-us.com ijwchb http://cheaperbeatsbyydre.com aqmkks http://fox-louisvuittonoutlet.com nsjbei [url=http://au-louisvuittonoutlet.com]louis vuitton outlet[/url] ylqoc [url=http://www.hots-canadagooseoutlet.com]canada goose outlet[/url] gilsg [url=http://www.montblanc-sale-us.com]cheap mont blanc[/url] zdqty [url=http://cheaperbeatsbyydre.com]dr dre beats[/url] hrlxxe [url=http://fox-louisvuittonoutlet.com]louis vuitton bags[/url] emjv

Anonymous said...

gyqvab http://au-louisvuittonoutlet.com hihojc http://www.hots-canadagooseoutlet.com ozgkgz http://www.montblanc-sale-us.com jeqaty http://cheaperbeatsbyydre.com wvfixo http://fox-louisvuittonoutlet.com yyotzm [url=http://au-louisvuittonoutlet.com]louis vuitton sale[/url] dswva [url=http://www.hots-canadagooseoutlet.com]canada goose jacket[/url] fsheb [url=http://www.montblanc-sale-us.com]cheap mont blanc[/url] rdkqr [url=http://cheaperbeatsbyydre.com]dr dre beats[/url] jsmucu [url=http://fox-louisvuittonoutlet.com]louis vuitton outlet[/url] gyai

Anonymous said...

tvbswy http://au-louisvuittonoutlet.com cuahol http://www.hots-canadagooseoutlet.com ahknbc http://www.montblanc-sale-us.com wzlbtz http://cheaperbeatsbyydre.com nwppoa http://fox-louisvuittonoutlet.com xqsuxu [url=http://au-louisvuittonoutlet.com]louis vuitton outlet[/url] ghlgm [url=http://www.hots-canadagooseoutlet.com]canada goose jacket[/url] skxgz [url=http://www.montblanc-sale-us.com]mont blanc pens[/url] lrvup [url=http://cheaperbeatsbyydre.com]cheap beats by dre[/url] vgbngn [url=http://fox-louisvuittonoutlet.com]louis vuitton bags[/url] qynz